Skip to main content
Education

DCA Claims or Fixed Commission? Know the Difference

Learn how DCA, high commission and lender ties differ, why fixed commission is not automatically unfair, and which questions to ask your finance provider.

Car Finance Refund Team
Last updated: 28 October 2026
3 min read

Key Takeaways

  • DCA, high commission and contractual ties are separate categories.
  • The high-commission test requires both percentage thresholds.
  • A fixed commission payment alone neither proves nor rules out a relevant complaint.

A DCA is one type of car finance commission arrangement. A fixed commission payment is different, and the existence of commission alone does not establish a right to compensation. The questions are what arrangement applied, what was disclosed and whether the agreement meets the relevant rules.

Reviewed 28 October 2026 against the FCA's current scheme guidance.

Discretionary commission arrangements

Under a DCA, the broker could influence the interest rate and increase its own commission by charging more. The FCA's ban took effect on 28 January 2021. That addressed the incentive created by the arrangement; it did not make every earlier finance agreement automatically eligible for a refund.

The FCA's final policy explanation includes exceptions, such as a DCA that was not used to earn discretionary commission, and other circumstances in which an arrangement is treated as fair.

Fixed commission and high commission

A fixed fee does not necessarily depend on the rate you paid. It is not automatically unfair simply because the broker received it.

The scheme can nevertheless cover an undisclosed high commission arrangement. The relevant threshold requires both commission of at least 39% of the total cost of credit and 10% of the loan. Meeting just one threshold is insufficient for that particular category. Other eligibility rules and exclusions also apply.

An example of the two thresholds

Assume a £10,000 loan, £2,000 total cost of credit and £900 commission:

  1. Step 1: Compare with credit cost. £900 ÷ £2,000 = 45%, which exceeds 39%.
  2. Step 2: Compare with the loan. £900 ÷ £10,000 = 9%, below 10%.
  3. Step 3: Read the result correctly. The hypothetical agreement does not meet both high-commission thresholds. That does not answer whether a DCA, relevant tie or another complaint issue exists.

These figures illustrate eligibility thresholds, not compensation.

Contractual ties between broker and lender

A contractual tie can mean the lender had exclusivity or first refusal. The scheme distinguishes this from cases where visible links between the lender, manufacturer and franchised dealer were established. A shared or similar name can be relevant to that exception.

Ask what the actual relationship was and what you were told. Do not assume a car badge proves either eligibility or exclusion.

Which dates matter

The wider scheme considers relevant motor finance agreements from 6 April 2007 to 1 November 2024. The 2021 DCA ban date does not cut off every high-commission or contractual-tie complaint.

Minimal commission, zero-interest borrowing, previous redress, high-value lending and other exclusions may affect the result. Our main claims guide explains these checks.

Questions to put to the lender

Ask it to identify the commission type and amount, whether the broker could vary the rate, any exclusivity or first-refusal arrangement, and the disclosure documents it relies on. Request an explanation of how those facts affect your assessment.

Expert Insight: The label “fixed commission” cannot settle the whole complaint. The amount, disclosure and any lender tie may also matter.

Common mistakes

Do not treat all undisclosed commission as an automatic refund, apply only one high-commission threshold, or confuse an eligibility threshold with the redress formula. A calculator cannot establish facts held in the lender's records.

The scheme remains partially suspended and the hearing is scheduled for February to March 2027. You can still complain directly for free; see our DCA complaint checklist.

Written By

Car Finance Refund Team

Published by Car Finance Refund Team. Check the article's sources and current lender or FCA guidance before acting on information about your agreement.

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or financial advice.

Prepare Your Car Finance Complaint

You can complain directly to your lender for free. Use our free complaint template, or choose the optional PDF generator with its price shown before checkout.

Create a Complaint Letter